LOS ANGELES MAYOR Antonio
Villaraigosa may need to watch his back. On December 4, the North
American Animal Liberation Press Office, a leading mouthpiece for
animal-rights extremists in the United States, posted on its Web site a
“communiqué” from a newly minted outfit called the Cat and Dog
Liberation Army. It read: “Villaraigosa deserves to be bumped off like
the dogs and cats we witnessed with their eyes wide, terrified before
they were bumped off. He got off way to [
sic] easy.”
The
unknown writer of the menacing note also bragged about vandalizing the
car and home of Deborah Villar, the mayor’s sister, in Rowland Heights.
The
threat and attack once again establish Los Angeles as the “epicenter”
of animal-rights extremism in the nation, according to Oren Segal,
co-director of the Anti-Defamation League’s Center on Extremism in New
York City, an international watchdog monitoring hate groups. “The Los
Angeles area is clearly experiencing a spike in this activity,” the
expert says. Segal, who describes the extremists as “professional” and
“hardcore,” believes law enforcement has a nearly impossible job in
front of it.
“Historically, a lot of this type of activity
remains unsolved,” Segal says. “It’s almost luck if someone is
arrested, and these groups are very hard to infiltrate. You have to be
able to talk the language, but people tend to smell a rat in this
movement.”
In August,
L.A.Weekly reported on the attempted firebombing
of Dr. Arthur Rosenbaum’s car in front of his home — Rosenbaum
performed animal testing for medical research at UCLA’s Jules Stein Eye
Institute. The Animal Liberation Front, an internationally known group
of underground extremists, followed up that attack in October with
another stealth mission at the Beverly Hills home of UCLA professor
Edythe London, who also conducts research using animals. Extremists
pumped water from a pool and flooded her residence, causing between
$20,000 and $30,000 in damage.
Keep Reading
The
FBI deemed both attacks to be acts of “domestic terrorism,” according
to spokeswoman Laura Eimiller, and they were just two of many attempts
by above- and underground activists to intimidate UCLA medical-research
staff in the past several years.
With no arrests made in the
UCLA cases, extremists appear to be “empowered,” according to Segal,
and they are now expanding their violent ways outside of Westwood. The
expert says there’s “almost certainly a link” between the attacks on
the UCLA professors and the mayor’s sister. “I don’t think there are
competing underground cells, by any means,” Segal says.
The FBI,
which is probing the UCLA incidents, and the Los Angeles Police
Department, which, along with the Sheriff’s Department, is probing the
vandalism against the mayor’s sister, have refused to comment about
such linkage, citing the need to keep details under wraps as they
pursue what they describe as active investigations.
A driving
force behind the underground movement is Dr. Jerry Vlasak, a Los
Angeles–based surgeon who co-founded the North American Animal
Liberation Press Office in 2004. “By providing these communiqués to the
public,” says Segal, “they’re trying to legitimize [the underground’s]
actions.”
Vlasak has told the
Weekly that his doctor
title lends credibility to the larger animal-rights movement — and, as
a result, he has become a very visible spokesman, appearing on
television and testifying before the U.S. Senate. But Vlasak is not one
of your good-humored, neighborhood doctors. In 2004, Vlasak told the
London Observer,
“I don’t think you’d have to kill too many [researchers]. I think for
five lives, 10 lives, 15 human lives, we could save a million, 2
million, 10 million nonhuman lives.”
A year later, Vlasak
engaged in a heated exchange with U.S. Senator Frank Lautenberg —
Vlasak was providing the activists’ point of view at a Senate hearing
looking into ways to combat eco-terrorism. A visibly perturbed
Lautenberg asked Vlasak where he practiced medicine. Vlasak vaguely
said the “Los Angeles area.” The senator asked him to narrow it down.
Vlasak, switching the locale, replied, “I practice at several hospitals
in the Riverside and San Bernardino area.”
Lautenberg asked him
to name one. Vlasak said, “Loma Linda University.” But that 2005
testimony to Congress, which lent Vlasak credibility with the media and
others, is utterly untrue, according to Joy Jameson, a spokeswoman at
Loma Linda University Medical Center. Jameson says Vlasak resigned from
“general surgery” in 1998 — and hasn’t worked at that hospital since
then.
Vlasak also claims he performs surgery at Riverside
Community Hospital. “He’s always telling people he works here,”
explains Norene Bowers, senior vice president of Patient Care Services.
She says that while Vlasak retains medical-staff “privileges” at
Riverside Community Hospital, he hasn’t performed surgery there in
nearly two years.
In an e-mail, Vlasak addressed these
discrepancies: “I have practiced at both Loma Linda University and
Riverside Community Hospital in the past, and still have privileges at
the latter location. Your focus on my employment record instead of the
suffering of nonhuman animals is deplorable.”
THE RECENT PUSH TO RATTLE
the mayor of Los Angeles and his sister comes after nearly three years
of protests by aboveground activists against the treatment of animals
at the city’s six shelters, according to North American Animal
Liberation Press Office spokeswoman Lindy Greene. Greene, who has led
demonstrations at UCLA, says the mayor’s sister Deborah Villar is now a
“tertiary target,” meaning someone who does not have direct influence
on city policy but may be pressured to talk to the mayor.
“It’s
a brilliant concept,” says Greene unashamedly. “Even though Deborah is
not entirely involved, the idea is that she would be very upset and
she’ll call Antonio and say, ‘Why do I have to suffer for something
you’re not doing?’ There’s a hope that she’ll apply pressure on him, or
he would feel guilty for what’s happening to his sister.”
Greene,
who lives in North Hollywood and describes herself as “one of the most
prominent animal-rights activists” in Los Angeles, has marched in front
of Villar’s home with others as they shouted their disgust into
bullhorns. Villar never replied to e-mails seeking comment, but Los
Angeles County Sheriff’s Department spokesman Steve Whitmore confirmed
that an unknown assailant or assailants poured a “corrosive” on
Villar’s car and splattered red paint on steps leading to her home,
creating total damage worth $3,500. The attack, says Whitmore, occurred
sometime between midnight and 7 a.m. on November 13, and Greene
believes the Cat and Dog Liberation Army is a “new [underground] cell.”
“It is probably a group that doesn’t want to call themselves Animal Liberation Front,” says Greene.
No
one has been arrested in the Villar case, according to Whitmore, and
the written threat against the mayor “has not been labeled a crime,”
says Los Angeles Police Department Deputy Chief Mike Downing, assistant
commanding officer of the Counter Terrorism Intelligence Center Bureau.
The City Attorney’s Office, which advised the LAPD, would not comment
on the threat because of “potential litigation,” spokesman Nick
Velasquez told the
Weekly. The Mayor’s Office has remained silent as well.
Greene
says the threat was merely someone acting out. “That, to me, is not
advocating [violence]. The activists are just expressing their anger.
They’re expressing their moral outrage.”
Segal doesn’t let her
off so easily. “That sounds like somebody who doesn’t want to take
responsibility for inciting violence,” he says. “Language is not just a
way to spout off. People take language very seriously in this movement.”
Downing,
who is working with the Sheriff’s Department, describes the attack on
Villar’s home as an act of “domestic terrorism.” “They are striking
fear into the hearts of innocent civilians by committing crime,” says
the deputy chief.
Some weeks ago, activists picketed a home they
identified as that of Villaraigosa chief of staff Robin Kramer, and a
much more recent “tertiary” target has been Maria Blackman, the ex-wife
of Villaraigosa’s deputy chief of staff, Jimmy Blackman, whose duties
include overseeing Los Angeles Animal Services. Greene says activists
have routinely protested at her home in the Valley over the past six
months, unfurling a large banner that read “Animal Killer in Your
Neighborhood.” On November 27, the Animal Liberation Front boasted in a
communiqué, also posted on the North American Animal Liberation Press
Office’s Web site, that they “paint strippered” a car in front of Maria
Blackman’s residence four days earlier.
The LAPD says the
solvent-pouring incident did not happen. “That’s a false claim,”
asserts Downing. Jimmy Blackman has refused several requests by the
Weekly to
specifically comment on the alleged attack, and Greene says, “[Law
enforcement] will lie about an action, saying it took place at the
wrong address. They want to make the Animal Liberation Front look like
idiots.”
Asked if the suspects in the various cases will be hard
to find, Downing replies, “We have incredibly skilled investigators,
and we have a very robust investigation. We are taking it extremely
seriously.” Both Downing and Sheriff’s spokesman Whitmore, citing a
need to be discreet, declined to say if police have beefed up security
around the mayor, his sister’s home or Maria Blackman’s home.
Greene
doesn’t expect the late-night attacks to end anytime soon. “If all of
this abuse [of animals] continues and law enforcement keeps the
pressure on us,” the spokeswoman says, “all indications show that these
actions are not only going to continue but increase.”
Los Angeles, in other words, may be facing a very troublesome new year.