AAFL Tickets
March 12, 2008
Launch 'MSU President Lou Anna K. Simon' Video: MSU President Lou An... Launch 'U.S. Attorney Charles Gross' Video: U.S. Attorney Charle...

Stan Clayton of Burton Brothers cleans up the rubble of the Institute of International Agriculture’s offices in Agriculture Hall on Jan. 13, 2000, after a suspected arson fire damaged the rooms.

Share this article on Facebook Digg this Add to del.icio.us Blogger RSS 2.0 Comment Feed

4 charged in 1999 arson

Investigation comes to a close after 8 years; MSU officials react

After more than eight years of investigation, police and MSU officials announced Tuesday the arrests of four suspects in connection with the 1999 arson of Agriculture Hall.

Detroit residents Frank Brian Ambrose, 33, Aren Bernard Burthwick, 27, and Stephanie Lynne Fultz, 27, and Cincinnati resident Marie Jeanette Mason, 46, each face four counts of conspiracy to commit arson, aggravated arson and arson in connection with the Agriculture Hall incident and a Jan. 1, 2000, arson of commercial logging equipment near Mesick, Mich.

The incident at Agriculture Hall caused more than $1 million in damage.

If convicted, the charges against each member of the group carry a minimum penalty of five years and a maximum penalty of 40 years in prison.

Officials from MSU police, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Michigan and the FBI were involved in the investigation.

“We certainly hope we’ve sent the message to these folks that time will not deter us,” said Andrew Arena, the FBI special agent in charge of the case.

The indictment states that all four suspects helped plan the arson of Agriculture Hall and that Mason and Ambrose executed it. It also states that all four suspects carried out the Mesick arson.

MSU police Chief Jim Dunlap said officers conducted the investigation across 10 states in search of suspects.

“We’ve been working on it nearly every day for the past eight years,” Dunlap said.

None of the suspects have any prior university affiliation, and none have any prior arrests, Dunlap said.

The arson targeted the Agriculture Biotechnology Support Project, or ABSP, a program that researches the use of genetically modified plants for use in Africa and other developing parts of the world, MSU President Lou Anna K. Simon said.

Shortly after the arson, an environmental group known as Earth Liberation Front took responsibility for the fire. The group is considered a threat by law enforcement officials because of its past involvement in acts of ecoterrorism.

The fire was started in the office of the ABSP director Catherine Ives and caused damage to the third and fourth floors of the northeast wing of Agriculture Hall.

Following the arson, the ABSP offices and some neighboring offices were relocated while repairs were made. It took about a year for the damages to be completely repaired, Dunlap said.

The arson caused more than $1 million in damage to equipment and facilities, but Simon said the real damage was done to the educational climate for university researchers.

“It was more than the destruction of property, it was an assault on the core value of free and open inquiry at a research university,” Simon said.

Eric Crawford, a professor in the Department of Agricultural, Food and Resource Economics, had an office on the second floor of Agriculture Hall during the arson.

Luckily, Crawford said, fellow professor David Schweikhardt was in his office and discovered the fire before it grew larger.

“I’m guessing that whoever set the fire wasn’t planning on having anybody around,” Crawford said.

“Had he not noticed the fire when he left, it could have burned the whole building.”

Crawford said the fire, which forced about 30 people to move out of their damaged offices, disrupted the work of everyone in that part of the building.

“It was a major disaster that affected units in our department as well as the Institute of International Agriculture,” he said.

The 1999 attack on Agriculture Hall was not the first time arsonists have targeted a university building.

In 1992, offices in Anthony Hall and research facilities on south campus were firebombed, resulting in another $1.2 million loss. The Animal Liberation Front claimed responsibility.

Published on Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Trackback URL: http://www.statenews.com/index.php/trackback/5177

Comments RSS 2.0 Comment Feed

Circus Anyone?
03/11/08 @ 4:39pm

Are these the same nutjobs writing into the SNs everyday about how circuses are bad?
This makes them a little less credible.

AM
03/11/08 @ 5:50pm

Now what I find ironic is they destroyed years of work for Karen Chou. It was her research to try and find alternatives to animal testing that they completely destroyed. While I don’t find it hilarious Karen Chou lost a lot of her work. I find it HILARIOUS that the ALF helped destroy the work of someone basically on their side. Ooooh irony. :-)

Jason Van Dyke
03/11/08 @ 7:36pm

Exactly the same people. They are probably not responding to this because they are too busy preparing a legal defense for their “freedom fighters.” I think I am going to eat a big steak tonight in their honor.

And I am surprised there are not MORE charged. There is federal statutory authority to charge these people with “Animal Enterprise Terrorism.” I did a research report on this law, which has existed for years, back when I was in law school. The law is 18 USC 43 and it has existed since 1992 and was updated with bi-partisan legislation in late 2006. Surprisingly, very few people have ever been prosecuted under the act.

Jason Van Dyke
03/11/08 @ 11:44pm

If anyone wants to read my commentary on why I think that there should be additional charges (specifically, terrorism charges) in this case, feel free to read my commentary here

or here

Both are the same commentary. The second link is my personal blog, and I welcome all comments, including opposing views, so long as they are civil and on-topic.

Tom Payne
03/12/08 @ 10:22am

This is good news.

Rob
03/12/08 @ 12:08pm

I agree with all of these comments. If you don’t like the system, change it. Don’t go fire-bombing buildings and expect to get sympathy….or more importantly, results.

Neato
03/12/08 @ 12:39pm

I think its a bit ironic Jason Van Dyke is asking for stiffer charges for the indicted. His claim to legitimacy as a man of the law is smashed to pieces by the fact he was banned from MSU after MSU cops found a gun in his rooms along with a copy of the Turner Diaries (which glorifies race war and hanging of blacks from L.A. lamp posts).

ESTO
03/12/08 @ 1:16pm

I remember this crime since we had an oddball neighbor who was questioned about it by the FBI. She had about 10 cats and was an “animal rights” extremist. Actually it was not only Karen Chou who lost her work. There was another professor (whose name I have forgotten) who was close to retirement and whose life’s work was this project, destroyed by the fire. At the time it was a huge event on campus. If some students or others (staff, etc.) had been in the building they might have perished: it was sheer good fortune that nobody died. The destruction of the research is a tragedy. The elderly professor decided to retire since his 20+ year project was utterly destroyed. The perpetrators should be charged as well with attempted murder, and there should be no sympathy (“that was so long ago, they were young and foolish”) for their terrorist actions.

Add a comment

All fields are required.
Your email address will not be published.
We need to verify that you are, in fact, human.
The State News reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.